Female Sexual Interest/Arousal Disorder- Full DSM 5 Text
Today we read and provide commentary on FSIAD, including diagnostic features, functional consequences, and a brief yet incomplete nod to asexuality, in the DSM-5
Featured MarketplACE vendor of the week
Dragonstorm Studios: Shop
Transcript
Courtney: Hello everyone and welcome back. My name is Courtney. I’m here with my spouse Royce. Together we are the Ace Couple and we are back for part four of talking about the medicalization of asexuality. Part one, we discussed the entire history of how these now thought to be psychological disorders have developed, dating all the way back to the 1100s and the good old-fashioned term of frigidity. Back when it was used in more of a religious context than a medical one, although it did later become as much.
Courtney: Part two, we talked about the current diagnosis in the ICD-11, that being hypoactive sexual desire disorder. And last week we began our dive into the DSM-five, which, unlike the ICD, has split HSDD into two distinctly gendered disorders, that being female sexual interest / arousal disorder and male hypoactive sexual desire disorder.
Courtney: Last week we pulled from the abridged desk reference, but today we are diving into the full text. Because there’s quite a bit more commentary. in the full DSM-five that does get cut for the shorter editions.
Courtney: So picking up where we left off, female sexual interest / arousal disorder is listed in the DSM first, so we’ll dig into that one here. Let’s all just see together how frustrated we get. This’ll be fun.
Courtney: So after listing the diagnostic criteria, which we reviewed last week, many of these criteria sound suspiciously like valid definitions of asexuality to begin with. It then goes on to flesh out diagnostic features. The first thing it points out is that interpersonal context must be taken into account when making this diagnosis. A “desire discrepancy” in which a woman has a lower desire for sexual activity than her partner is not sufficient to diagnose female sexual interest / arousal disorder.
Courtney: And goes on to reference the above criterion. Says it’s not just when a woman wants less sex than her, the way it’s written, presumably male partner.
Royce: Of course.
Courtney: Of course.
Royce: As is tradition.
Courtney: As is customary. So they say, no, no, no, a desire discrepancy isn’t enough. A woman has to have absence or reduced interest in sexual activity. Or absent or reduced sexual / erotic thoughts or fantasies. The list goes on.
Courtney: There may be different symptom profiles across women as well as variability in how sexual interest and arousal are expressed. For example, in one woman, sexual interest / arousal disorder may be expressed as a lack of interest in sexual activity. An absence of erotic or sexual thoughts and reluctance to initiate sexual activity and respond to a partner’s sexual invitations.
Courtney: All right, diagnose me now. In another woman, an inability to become sexually excited, to respond to sexual stimuli with sexual desire, and a corresponding lack of signs of physical sexual arousal may be the primary features. Because sexual desire and arousal frequently coexist and are elicited in response to adequate sexual cues, the criteria for female sexual interest arousal disorder takes into account that difficulties in desire and arousal often simultaneously characterize the complaints of women with this disorder. Short-term changes in sexual interest or arousal are common and may be adaptive responses to events in a woman’s life that do not represent a sexual dysfunction.
Courtney: It then goes on to reiterate that it needs to be for a minimum duration of six months as listed in the criterion.
Royce: Long enough for the common known hormonal changes that happen during a person’s lifetime to not qualify.
Courtney: What’s so interesting to me about that, they’re like, short-term doesn’t count, but six months? six months is nothing to me these days.
Royce: Well, I was just wondering, six months seems short to me as well, because I’ve heard of people talk about drastic changes either immediately after childbirth or like during menopause. And I haven’t heard a timeframe on things like that, but six months does seem kind of short.
Courtney: Just in general, think about the last six months of our lives. It’s gone by in a flash. But recall, as you will, despite the fact that they’re adamant that there needs to be a minimum duration of six months, they also specify that there is lifelong female sexual interest arousal disorder. So they aren’t just looking at changes or reductions that they perceive or hope to be temporary. They’re saying, “Okay, after six months of not experiencing what we deem to be appropriate interest, desire, arousal, that’s when we’re gonna start calling it a problem. But if you’ve always been this way your entire life since puberty, still a problem.” There may be absent or reduced frequency or intensity of interest in sexual activity, which was previously termed hypoactive sexual desire disorder. So they actively admit directly in the text that this disorder is a direct stemming from HSDD, which we talked about previously having significant flaws for being put in these texts initially.
Courtney: The frequency or intensity of sexual and erotic thoughts or fantasies may be absent or reduced. The expression of fantasies varies widely across women and may include memories of past sexual experiences. What really does get me, and maybe someday when I mysteriously have enough time on my hands, I’ll start digging through just other selected at random disorders in the DSM to see if anything else parallels this language.
Courtney: But they’re trying to emphasize like, no, this isn’t just a desire discrepancy. It’s not just if it’s six months. It’s not just this, that, or the other thing. But they also go on to be like, you know, when we’re talking about fantasies in general, this varies widely. Everyone’s a little different, and you have to take into consideration that everyone’s a little different.
Courtney: So if there’s no objective norm, why are they building an entire disorder around a mythical norm when they themselves are saying these expressions very drastically. So what exactly is it that you feel the need to label, diagnose, attempt to treat or cure?
Royce: I mean, some of this you’ve already answered in past episodes about this whole concept being something that certain aspects of society have seen as an affront and tried to correct in some way for a very, very long time. But also with a book like the DSM, how many different authors and different researchers does it have? How many things are brought in at different points in time? I think that you said that some of these diagnoses predated modern rigorous standards.
Courtney: Yeah.
Royce: And if you gutted the entire book and forced the DSM-six to actually reevaluate everything according to modern standards, it wouldn’t make the cut.
Courtney: Yeah, that is my understanding of it. And there there are there are like panels. They’re like boards that are assembled to oversee individual like chapters of these things. So yeah, lots of different inputs are going into the final product.
Courtney: And-
Royce: I mean, it is entirely possible that one person in one area is very aware of and trying to accommodate nuance, at least in their specific area, and then someone else is writing a different section of the book who is very rigid in their viewpoint of what humanity is supposed to be.
Courtney: And honestly, that is exactly what the writing- like, the fleshing out the diagnostic features, the supporting diagnosis, and these- that’s what it feels like. It feels like someone said, “This is normal, and if you don’t have it, it’s wrong,” and then someone else couldn’t actually get this entire thing removed, so they’re like, “Well, actually, there’s nuance. Actually, everyone’s different.
Courtney: Actually—” Because it’s like so wishy-washy as to not actually be useful. So they also say, “The normative decline in sexual thoughts with age should be taken into account when the criterion is being assessed.” Which they also use that word normative again, normative decline in sexual thoughts. I know plenty of older people who would be adamant that it is an incorrect stereotype. Like allosexual old people who are like, like, actually, I’m having the best sex of my life right now at this ripe old age. So sure, even if there is an average decline, like, I I just object to anything pertaining to sex, sexuality, gender identity, gender expression being clinically deemed normative. The entire attempt to define normativity in these ranges does every human a disservice.
Courtney: Absence or reduced frequency of initiating sexual activities and of receptivity to a partner’s sexual invitations is a behaviorally focused criterion. A couple’s beliefs and preferences for sexual initiation patterns are highly relevant to the assessment of this criteria. Tell me any diagnosable, treatable, like, medical condition you can think of that relies on what you and your presumably straight, cis, hetero, monogamous partner believe should be.
Courtney: Because also, let’s say, let’s say we’ve got like a quiverful Christian couple kind of a situation, and they’re living in a culture and a community and a belief that they will absolutely not use birth control. God is going to give them as many children as they are meant to have, and they need to give God as many opportunities as possible to bless them with children. And if their quiver is full of arrows, if their house is full of kids, they’ve they’ve succeeded at being a good Christian couple and family. And one party’s like, yeah, we need to be making as many opportunities as possible to have babies.
Courtney: And the other one’s like, “Eh, you know, I’m not really feeling it tonight.” Maybe they aren’t really feeling it for like six months. Maybe they’re not really feeling it for six months after having a child. Now the DSM is literally saying, “A couple’s beliefs and preferences for sexual initiation patterns are highly relevant to the assessment of whether or not she has female sexual interest arousal disorder.”
Courtney: That’s ridiculous.
Royce: If you were to go look up some older diagnostic criteria, it’s probably only a small step away from hysteria.
Courtney: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely it is.
Courtney: I mean, just like we talked about in the first episode, like frigidity has waffled back and forth over the years in context about whether or not men and women can both be frigid or if it’s just a thing that women can be. But no, you’re really telling like, diagnostic professionals that you should take into consideration the couple’s beliefs and preferences.
Courtney: Because beliefs and preferences, I mean, even outside of strict religious context, like, society has our own normativities that are just passively or actively put upon us our entire lives. People can feel like there is a standard that you’re supposed to be held to. And feel bad for not meeting it.
Courtney: But why, especially in interests of sex and sexuality, is it, “Well, let’s get you closer to where society thinks you should be,” instead of, “Hey, maybe this is just how you are. Maybe this is okay. Maybe let’s figure out how to have a happy, fulfilling life with the deck you’ve been handed, with the way you are.”
Courtney: Assessment of the adequacy of sexual stimuli will assist in determining if there is a difficulty with responsive sexual desire. It goes on to say that this may include reduced vaginal lubrication, but because physiological measures of genital sexual response do not differentiate women who report sexual arousal concerns from those who do not, the self-report of reduced or absent genital or non-genital sensations is sufficient. This is also kind of why, because I have long promised that we will one day speak about all of the proposed definitions of asexuality and how no matter what one single definition is used, it’s going to leave something out. There are definitely almost fandom-like communities that pop up online that get so adamant about one definition versus another. that I really think on the whole becomes detrimental to the entire community.
Courtney: And my hope is that by actually looking at the places where we can be discriminated against, where we can be offered conversion therapy, where we can be subjected to higher scrutiny, to see things like this. The DSM for this vague disorder it doesn’t care if you have adequate vaginal lubrication or not. The problem is that you don’t have interest in sexual activity. Or maybe you do, but you don’t have sexual or erotic thoughts. Or maybe you do, but you don’t initiate sexual activity.
Courtney: Medical settings lump all of these things in with one another. And I have unfortunately seen fights within the community in various comment sections and forums. about where is the line between asexual as an identity and a medical disorder or something that might be able to be cured. And oftentimes a lot of it comes down to like a normative worldview of genital functioning. They’re like, there’s nothing wrong with our bodies. Being asexual is just an orientation and an identity.
Courtney: We’re not broken. There’s nothing wrong with our bodies. Our bodies work perfectly fine.
Courtney: It’s all about attraction. It’s just the fact that we’re not attracted externally to other people.
Courtney: First of all, not the case for all aces. Really alienating for those who may be questioning, but also completely irrelevant when we’re talking about medical settings like this. For a diagnosis of female sexual interest / arousal disorder to be made, clinically significant distress must accompany the symptoms. Distress may be experienced as a result of the lack of sexual interest / arousal, or as a result of significant interference in a woman’s life and well-being. This is where it says, “If a lifelong lack of sexual desire is better explained by one’s self-identification as ‘asexual’ then a diagnosis of female sexual interest arousal disorder would not be made.”
Royce: Just from an information outlining perspective, it seems like they buried that too deep into the text. I feel like that should be an opener, like, “Keep this in mind as you’re reading the rest of the material below,” not for the people who haven’t already found the solution they were looking for and stopped reading, like, beyond that point.
Courtney: Well, the fascinating thing to me is, and we will get there in a page or two. There is a section for differential diagnosis, and asexuality is also not mentioned there. And that’s like, okay, I’m considering this as a diagnosis for this person, but let me take another look. What else could this be? Is there anything I’ve overlooked?
Courtney: And just like we stated, if you’ll recall our first episode about the history and development of these diagnoses, the fact that asexual is mentioned at all is a direct result of the work of activists who did organize on AVEN. And again, wonderful, fabulous work that they did.
Courtney: Unfortunately, the message just did not seem to be received as well as we had hoped. It’s definitely not nothing, but this little note about being asexual is also not under the male ace FSDD, which- so many problems. So many problems with that. It goes on to talk about associated features supporting diagnosis. Female sexual interest / arousal disorder is frequently associated with problems in experiencing orgasm, pain experienced during sexual activity, infrequent sexual activity, and couple-level discrepancies in desire.
Courtney: It seems like those are all not the same thing. You’re telling me they’re dump- they’re dumping pain during sexual activity with infrequent sexual activity? Those two things seem like one might be a problem while the other should never be considered a problem. Relationship difficulties and mood disorders are also frequently associated features of female sexual interest / arousal disorder. “Unrealistic expectations and norms regarding the ‘appropriate’ level of sexual interest or arousal, along with poor sexual ‘techniques’ and lack of information about sexuality, may also be evident in women diagnosed with female sexual interest / arousal disorder.” Is it funny to anyone else that “poor sexual technique” is like an associated feature supporting a diagnosis in the DSM? Like, does no one else find that objectively ridiculous?
Royce: I have medically determined that you’re bad at this.
Courtney: You’re bad at sex.
Royce: What is the medical remedy for that? If you get diagnosed with bad at sex, what does the doctor say you should do?
Courtney: Get good. That- see, this, this is why I hate it, because it’s a hilarious question, but the answers can get too real too fast.
Royce: What was the wording on that? Did you say improper technique?
Courtney: Poor sexual technique.
Royce: I was trying to rationalize that going back to the pain during sex, and it’s like, maybe there is something that you’re actually doing wrong and hurting yourself.
Courtney: Oh no! Which, and then to also say lack of information about sexuality is so odd, because to me that suggests maybe this person is asexual and they don’t know that word and they don’t know that’s an option. Or in another case, maybe this person is, you know, gay or bi, and they just haven’t come to terms with that yet or haven’t been able to explore that yet. Which, if that’s the case, definitely not not female sexual interest or arousal disorder. That seems like a completely different thing, actually.
Courtney: In addition to the subtypes lifelong / acquired and generalized / situational, the following five factors must be considered during assessment. Assessment and diagnosis. one, partner factors. Example: partner’s sexual problems, partner’s health status. two, relationship factors. Poor communication, discrepancies in desire for sexual activity. three, individual vulnerability factors. Poor body image, history of sexual or emotional abuse. Psychiatric comorbidity: depression, anxiety. or stressors—job loss, bereavement. four, cultural or religious factors—inhibitions relating to prohibitions against sexual activity, attitudes toward sexuality. And five, medical factors relevant to prognosis, course, or treatment. Note that each of these factors may contribute differently to the presenting symptoms of different women. with this disorder.
Courtney: And it just says these all must be considered in addition to the subtypes. So it’s not saying that if you have any of these things that you wouldn’t make this diagnosis, which is equally weird to me because I frankly don’t think that your relationship status should ever influence your personal medical history and diagnoses and treatments. And it gets a little, you know, trickier to talk about when you talk about history of sexual abuse, history of emotional abuse, because there’s a very, very big stigma that asexuality isn’t real, you’re just traumatized. And some people, even within the asexual community, will unfortunately echo these points. But that just goes back to the like, no, we’re not broken, there’s nothing wrong with us.
Courtney: Which unfortunately does a lot of harm to the disabled aces in our community, the aces who do have history of trauma. There are people that I know who identify as asexual and they do actively attribute their asexuality to a past trauma. A lot of aces in the community would say that person is not actually asexual. But knowing some of these people, myself getting to know them, being in community with them, I have seen that asexuality has become a very freeing label, community, a safe place for them, and has become a net positive in their life. So I am not here to play the game saying, if you have trauma, maybe it’s not asexuality, maybe you could see if it could get cured, because my base understanding Step one, where I’m always going to come from, is if someone doesn’t want to have sex, why is society’s first response to try to make that person have sex?
Courtney: Because that is fundamentally rape culture. It is problematic. And that in a lot of ways is what diagnoses like this are doing.
Courtney: Quite frankly, I do not care what “reason”— whether a “reason” exists or not, “reason” with heavy scare quotes- someone has for having absent or reduced interest in sexual activity, I think it is weird if your knee-jerk reaction is, “We should fix that. You should have more of that.” However, all of that said, if we are looking at psychiatric comorbidities as an example, depression, anxiety, let’s say someone with their full heart believes, “I am an allosexual person. I was before I got depressed.” My libido tanked while I had depression, and yeah, this is a problem.
Courtney: I do kind of want it back. I want to be happier, for one, but I also want, you know, my flourishing sex life back.
Courtney: If that is what that individual person thinks and believes, and they do seek medical assistance, I do kind of question why this person in their charts would need to have two different diagnoses in the first place. Like, why would they have depression and female sexual interest arousal disorder? And I have to question that because I’ve seen that myself in my own medical charts, and not even speaking um psychologically, but as someone with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome and suspected mast cell activation syndrome and all of these things which are known comorbidities and can be had by someone in isolation without having the other three. I understand why all of those are diagnoses, but I look back at my charts and I have had so many weird little diagnoses throughout the years just tacked on, and some of them are really more of a symptom than an actual disorder.
Courtney: And a lot of them are kind of just, here’s a made-up phrase or a made-up syndrome. I’m gonna say basically symptom syndrome is what you have because I don’t know what else to put here, but clearly this is a problem. And a lot of those get dropped over time entirely, or they get understood to be, yeah, this is just a symptom of one of the overarching things you have. Or like EDS itself, as a kid I went through, oh, it’s nursemaid’s elbow, it’s growing pains, it’s hypermobility syndrome, it’s ligament laxity. I had all of those things.
Courtney: Things before it was understood, oh, Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome is what the diagnosis is, and this actually has diagnostic criterion that can be observed and tested. But I’ve had a ton of things put in my chart that haven’t even been said to my face, and I’m looking at my chart after the fact and I’m like, what is this thing that says I have this diagnosis? And then I look it up and it says, oh, this isn’t a real diagnosis, this is just kind of a thing doctors say when they don’t know what else it could be. So I know that this happens in medical settings already. So that’s why I’m extremely skeptical of, okay, if this person is known to have depression and they think it could be a symptom of this, why do we have to name this as a disorder even in that situation? And I ask these questions just because I am genuinely in my mind trying to understand in what case this is actually an accurate, helpful diagnosis for someone.
Courtney: And I as of yet do not understand. I don’t see one.
Royce: Yeah, it seems like the criteria are either none of your business, not your concern, or they are symptoms of something else that is already diagnosable.
Courtney: Or just someone having an idea for what something should be and fretting about not meeting that standard. But like, think about all other like life milestones. There’s no other like comparable- and yeah, granted, I I will grant you, sexual activity does involve bodies and minds, so I can see why doctors may be looking at it. But yes, a societal notion of what the correct amount of sexual interest is, the correct amount of sexual activity is, the correct number of times a week you should be having sex with your partner, and they start feeling like it’s a problem because they aren’t meeting that expectation. Why all of a sudden is it the problem they’re not meeting that expectation and not that society has this expectation to begin with? Because let’s think about like, you know, in our country, home ownership is like a big milestone for like a happy, healthy life and the American dream, right?
Courtney: And a thing we’re told from a very young age that it should be attainable to us. We should aspire to own our own home. More and more people are rethinking that, as they should, but it’s also less attainable to a lot of people. If someone is like genuinely fretting, you know, I hit 40 and I don’t even own my own home yet. And this is bothering them so much because society has always told them that this is how you have a good, happy life. This is how you’ve succeeded.
Courtney: You wouldn’t diagnose that person with- you know, maybe you can diagnose them as poor. But it’s not a perfect equivalent, but they are related in that there are interconnected systems of oppression that in this case would be causing distress to the person at the end of the day. There are economic systems of oppression, capitalism, things that are making it more and more difficult to obtain the things that we were always brought up to say is what’s gonna lead you to a happy life. On the other hand, we have things like allonormativity, patriarchy, misogyny- these are cultural systems of oppression. And these structures, as I’ve said time and time again, harm everyone.
Courtney: In a situation of allonormativity, it’s disproportionately going to affect asexual people and others who do not fit into that neat tidy box. of what society deems to be normal and appropriate and healthy and needed for a happy life. So it might sound flippant to say, “Oh, you don’t diagnose someone with poor,” but when you think of it that way, as people suffering as a result of oppressive systems, it doesn’t sound so silly anymore. Are they terrible systems? Yes.
Courtney: Do they do harm? Yes. Do they need to be dismantled? Yes. But short of literally dismantling all of these oppressive systems, which no individual person can do, no society can do immediately, what else are you gonna do in that situation? Sexuality, for some reason, has such a long history of being medicalized, so the answer to that seems to be slap a diagnosis on it.
Courtney: In an instance of economic disparity, well, what would you do in that situation? You’d say, well, if this is out of your control, if this is not the circumstance you’re currently living in, then you need to find other avenues for having a happy life. And maybe home ownership isn’t for you. And have you considered that maybe home ownership isn’t even that great? Maybe you’d rather rent uh because someone else will, you know, fix any structural damage if it happens. There’s actually benefits to living in a different way.
Courtney: Maybe it’s never been presented to you. I don’t know. Now I’m I’m going on a tangent now.
Courtney: I kind of know where I’m going, but if someone genuinely in their heart of hearts just does not have interest in sexual activity, they’re like, I just don’t want this. I don’t even have sexual fantasies.
Courtney: Then that’s kind of just the circumstances they’re in right now. How do you work with that? A comprehensive understanding of asexuality is one avenue to open their eyes to different ways of thinking and being, and might be a very freeing understanding for them.
Royce: It’s also just not a general practitioner’s job to solve that problem, and they need to understand that. You get what I mean?
Royce: Like, there are a lot of reasons why this stems from certain doctors making a problem out of something that isn’t actually a problem.
Courtney: There is probably a lot of truth in that.
Royce: Or at least not a medical problem. If someone is struggling to understand themselves and how they fit into society and how they find their own happiness, and part of that is self-awareness and getting to know their own orientation and whatnot, that’s not something you go to like a medical practitioner for. It might be something you discuss in therapy or with the right community of friends or something like that. If you are diagnosed with poor, there are financial advisors that can maybe- like, there are limits with the situation that you’re born into and have personal habits and all sorts of things that determine that situation. But the path there is not in a doctor’s office, right?
Royce: There it’s a completely different thing to analyze and think through and try to figure out what the solution might be, whether that solution is changing something or just being more comfortable with your reality.
Courtney: Which, I mean, you bring up therapy, and since this is, you know, the DSM, these are psychiatric concerns, so very often things diagnosed in these books are going to go hand in hand with some type of therapy. I know firsthand how harmful and damaging certain therapists can be. But I know there are also like success stories for couples therapy, for example. So if there is a couple who are on the same page about sex and sexuality, and they’ve got whatever their own personal issues are that they’re trying to work through, and they do decide that couples therapy is the avenue for working through that.
Courtney: I still question the use of this disorder because to me, and this is sort of an issue with medicine on the whole, is that at least under the current medical system we have, it very often doesn’t treat you as an individual. And every individual doctor is like just pulling one little piece of your individual history and laser focusing on it and not even looking at everything that might be, you know, coexisting together or informing one another, I still question the utility of this disorder. Because if whatever straight couple they’re picturing when they write these things is maybe going into couples therapy to work through something, even while you’re working through that process, why why does this disorder actually help?
Courtney: Why why is this label being in their chart something that would help?
Royce: I don’t think it does.
Courtney: I don’t think it does. I don’t think it does.
Courtney: Because for me, with all of my various diagnoses that I have, a lot of them have been a huge relief when I finally got the right word, the right phrase, the right diagnosis, because now I have the language. I can explain what my challenges are, and that in turn, over time, helps me better advocate for my own accessibility needs, my own medical care.
Royce: It also helps you find the boundaries of it too. Like the number of times you’ve searched EDS, space, whatever weird thing was happening to you at the moment, and like found threads about other people being like, oh, apparently these things are correlated.
Courtney: Yes, absolutely. Because this does sort of put in a couple situation, if the problem is not having enough sex, this is kind of putting the blame on the one who isn’t wanting the sex. And again, this is a theoretical couple situation. Like, well, you’re the one with the problem, you’re the one with the disorder, you’re the one that needs to be cured.
Courtney: That’s still far too close for comfort to just patriarchal standards of a woman needs to please her husband, a woman needs to be sexually available for her husband. I’d like to think that maybe there’s a therapist out there who would use a diagnosis like this to try to explain to the partner, you know, this is something you need to have empathy for, this is something you need to temper your expectations because this is a valid diagnosis that she has, and to try to pull, you know, the non-sexually disordered partner down a little closer. But my history with medical professionals and psychiatrists and just being a woman in this world doesn’t doesn’t give me high hopes.
Courtney: It really doesn’t. So then it goes on to talk about prevalence. The prevalence of female sexual interest / arousal disorder as defined in this manual is unknown.
Courtney: ’Cause we don’t have enough studies about this. We don’t have quality scientific analysis about this. We’re just going on vibes.
Courtney: The prevalence of low sexual desire and of problems with sexual arousal as defined by DSM-IV or ICD-10 may vary markedly in relation to age, cultural setting, duration of symptoms, and presence of distress. Again, it’s all about culture.
Courtney: Although I do find interesting, it goes on to say, “When distress about sexual functioning is required, prevalence estimates are markedly lower. Some older women report less distress about low sexual desire than younger women, although sexual desire may decrease with age.” So that reminds me of the uh statistic we pointed out in the first episode where up to 50% of women have this problem. Well, if it’s 50% of women, maybe it’s not a problem.
Courtney: They’re like, when we say you have to be significantly distressed, we think there are fewer people. So that does sort of uh imply that before that significant distress, they just thought a lot more people had this. And they’re attributing to sexual desire decreasing with age for why older women report less distress than younger women, but I’m also just- I’m more inclined to chalk that up to maturing. Almost a high percentage of people I know, as they age, get more confidence in their self, think less about what other people think, start to break free of societal norms, and are completely comfortable with that.
Courtney: It baffles me. That that is not pointed out here. It points out the development and course. By definition, lifelong female sexual interest / arousal disorder suggests that the lack of sexual interest or arousal has been present for the woman’s entire sexual life.
Courtney: Who woulda thunk? But then it says that the acquired subtype would be assigned if the difficulties with sexual interest or arousal developed after a period of non-problematic sexual functioning. So that does kind of uh imply that- they’re they’re calling it problematic sexual functioning.
Courtney: Now let’s do this little experiment. So, okay, I meet several of these things on this criterion, which they deem to be problematic sexual functioning. The only reason why they wouldn’t diagnose me with this is because I self-identify as, quote, “asexual.” Every asexual should literally keep an ace up their sleeve every time they go to see a psychiatrist, and anytime a sexual dysfunction gets brought up, literally, ace in the sleeve. Just pull it out.
Courtney: That’s my trump card. No.
Courtney: Risk and prognostic factors, they say, are temperamental, environmental, and genetic and physiological. Environmental factors being like relationship status, relationship difficulties, your partner’s history, your upbringing, etc. Temperamental factors include negative cognitions and attitudes about sexuality and past history of mental disorders. Differences in propensity for sexual excitation and sexual inhibition may also predict the likelihood of developing sexual problems. And under genetic and physiological, they talk again about some medical conditions like diabetes, uh thyroid dysfunction, um which they say are examples for risk factors for female sexual interest / arousal disorder. I also personally know aces with both of those disorders who would object to saying that that medical condition of theirs is causing their asexuality.
Courtney: There appears to be strong influence of genetic factors on vulnerability to sexual problems in women. But then it says, “Psychophysiological research using vaginal—” oh, let’s give this big word a shot— “photoplethysmography”— it’s probably about as close as we’re gonna get- “has not found differences between women with and without perceived lack of genital arousal. So that implies to me that they have used equipment to try to measure blood volume changes vaginally in women and have actually not found any difference. So I suppose I’m left to assume that’s why they consider this to be psychiatric, because, well, it’s not that particular physiological problem. But again, is it a problem?
Courtney: Culture-related diagnostic issues. There is marked variability in prevalence rates of low desire across cultures. Lower rates of sexual desire may be more common among East Asian women compared with Euro-Canadian women. Although the lower levels of sexual desire and arousal found in men and women from East Asian countries compared with Euro-American groups groups may reflect less interest in sex in those cultures. The possibility remains that such group differences are an artifact of the measures used to quantify desire. A judgment about whether low sexual desire reported by a woman from a certain ethnocultural group meets criteria for female sexual interest / arousal disorder must take into account the fact that different cultures may pathologize some behaviors and not.
Courtney: Others. I do really hate that they have to bring in, you know, East Asian women and East Asian men, because we have talked a lot about the intersection of asexuality and various ethnicities. Aces of different races, so to speak, have their own set of stigmas around them. I’ve known asexual men, for example, who are themselves Asian, who have often fretted about playing into negative stereotypes because of the stereotype of a desexualized Asian man. Much the same way disabled ace people often feel like they may be playing into the negative stereotype of a desexualized disabled person. I don’t know, I’m trying to sort out all of my complex feelings on seeing this written in the DSM, because I’m sure someone would make the argument that they are trying to be intersectional by talking about different cultures and the fact that, you know, one size might not fit all.
Courtney: But on the other hand, if a doctor reading this doesn’t actually have lived experience or personal connections with people from those cultures, is that just becoming a stereotype in their head that can negatively impact patient encounters now and in the future? I would venture to guess, yeah, probably.
Courtney: And if we have an entire section of culture-related diagnostic issues for, well, you know, if this person is Euro-Canadian, if this Euro-Canadian woman isn’t having enough sexual desire, she probably has a disorder and that’s a problem. But I don’t know if this East Asian woman shows a similar lack of interest. Maybe she’s just Asian.
Courtney: That doesn’t sound good. That’s none of this is good.
Courtney: And I think it really is just more evidence for why we shouldn’t let culture dictate medical diagnoses. I think if there’s any sort of argument to be made that someone could be diagnosed with this in this culture but not in that one, it’s probably not a valid diagnosis. Gender-related diagnostic issues, by definition. The diagnosis of female sexual interest / arousal disorder is only given to women. Distressing difficulties with sexual desire in men would be considered under male hypoactive sexual desire disorder. And this one is my favorite because this entire subsetting in bold.
Courtney: Functional consequences. of female sexual interest / arousal disorder. What are the functional consequences?
Courtney: Why do we really need this diagnosis to name a problem? Because the functional consequences- a single sentence: difficulties in sexual interest / arousal are often associated with decreased relationship satisfaction.
Courtney: Okay. All right.
Courtney: Then we get to the differential diagnosis. Again, asexuality is not in the differential diagnosis. We have non-sexual mental disorders, substance or medication use, another medical condition, interpersonal factors, other sexual dysfunctions, or inadequate or absent sexual stimuli. Now here it does kind of contradict itself a little bit, which I find interesting, because under another medical condition, it says, “If the sexual symptoms are considered to be almost exclusively associated with the effects of another medical condition,” Then a diagnosis of female sexual interest arousal disorder would not be made. It gives a few examples, including thyroid dysfunction and diabetes. Which previously, on just the page before, it says, “Diabetes and thyroid dysfunction can be risk factors for female sexual interest arousal disorder.”
Courtney: Literally on one page, this is a risk factor. If they have this, they might also get this. On the next page, “No, if they have this, you wouldn’t make this diagnosis.”
Courtney: Who is editing this? That’s poor writing, even if I thought this was a valid diagnosis. And of course, under interpersonal factors, it does say that if things like severe relationship distress, intimate partner violence, um, other significant stressors are at play, then a diagnosis of female sexual interest arousal disorder would not be made.
Courtney: Sure, that makes sense to me. I don’t know why it doesn’t reiterate, you know, if asexuality could be a factor here, a diagnosis would not be made, just to really, you know, drive that home. But the fact that the only line about asexual here is one’s self-identification. On one hand, yes, we should have the unilateral ability to self-identify as asexual, correct.
Courtney: But they go on to talk about, you know, maybe Asians just don’t wanna have as much sex as as the Westerners do. So maybe that’s the real problem.
Courtney: There there really isn’t a definition of asexuality here, which kind of makes sense because if you put a definition of asexuality side by side with these diagnostic criteria on it’s gonna be a little too close for comfort. But there is nothing here that would guide a mental health professional toward opening that up as a conversation about, “Have you heard of asexuality? Is this something that sounds like it could apply to you?”
Courtney: There’s really no avenue for that carved out in this text. There are some very fascinating differences in the text. at least in my opinion, between the female sexual interest arousal disorder and the male hypoactive sexual desire. Um, I tangent far too long, so we are in fact going to have to come back again next week now to discuss the male hypoactive sexual desire disorder and then sort of parallel some of the differences in the text between the two, because I do think the differences are really, really telling of the mindset of the people who write and edit and, you know, finalize the language of these disorders. All of which I think starts from a fundamentally flawed premise to begin with.
Courtney: But for today, I am going to go ahead and leave you all off as always with today’s featured marketplace vendor, Dragonstorm Studios, an ace artist offering fantasy art prints, original illustrations, enamel pins, and the ‘and more’ really got my attention as there are books available, and I do so love to read. This is a Canadian vendor, so I’m especially going to recommend that you hop on over there if you yourself are in Canada. Since I am not, and shipping between countries is hell lately, I decided to pop over to their Alternate website where you can actually get ebooks, of which there are already four options.
Courtney: Uh, Echoes really caught my eye. Echoes is a collection of short stories and poems written with anthropomorphic animals in mind. From tales of magic at the dawn of civilization to historical fiction of the antiquity and beyond, may they inspire you to dream of worlds all your own. Or if you do want a physical book, over on the Dragonstorm Studios website, there is a physical copy of Farflung, which just the artwork on this cover alone is gorgeous.
Courtney: Although, can I tell you, I was I’ve very seriously considered ordering uh these little ribbons because I’ve been DMing Curse of Strahd for almost two years now. And there’s a little ribbon that says, “Marked safe?” from werewolves. And I really wanted to order that, and the first time you all fought and succeeded against a werewolf encounter, I really just wanted to pull that ribbon out to give to you.
Royce: We still haven’t had a werewolf encounter.
Courtney: Only normal wolves, dire wolves even. But yeah, I really wanted to have that in my back pocket, but for as adorable as this little ribbon is, shipping is more expensive than the ribbon itself, which is too bad. And I am trying to be a little more mindful of how many things I actually order and ship to my house, because there’s always gonna be a little bit of an environmental factor there. But I love it so much, so I just had to call that out, especially if you’re in Canada, especially if you like me are DMing Curse of Strahd or just want to threaten people with a werewolf.
Courtney: This ribbon’s great. I also really like- “Would you love me if I was a wyrm?” Spelled with a Y and has a little dragon tail on it. I was gonna get that one too. But for now, I am happy with my ebook. And I might be coming back for another one in the future. We shall see.
Courtney: So as always, you can find Dragonstorm Studios in the show notes on our website, as well as the description box if you happen to be listening on YouTube. And as always, thank you all so much for being here. We will talk to you all next time where maybe we’ll actually conclude this little series about asexual medicalization. One more diagnosis to go. Male hypoactive sexual desire disorder, we are coming for you. All right, goodbye.